These come highly recommended from the experts I follow-
All released within the past year.
The Whispers of Rocks - Anjana Khatwa: Blending indigenous stories and modern understanding of our world.
Strata: Stories From Deep Time- Laura Poppick: Review by Edward Valauskas.
A Little History of the Earth- Jamie Woodward- Kirkus Review.
I hope to read them soon. Happy reading :)
Russia, France, and the U.S. offered personnel and technical help along the way, but the lion's share of the credit goes to geologists of the Oil and Natural Gas Corporation for their perseverance and resilience in the face of immense challenges.
Dr. Deshpande joined the ONGC in its early days in 1961 and describes vividly his field experience in remote locales all across the country, from scorching Kutch, to steep Himalaya terrain, to facing personal danger during an insurgency in Assam. There were inevitable career challenges along the way due to changing institutional structure and unrealistic political expectations. Their impact on company work culture and productivity is described in honest and direct language.
One of my favorite passages comes towards the end of the book where he explains the divergence between geologists and management in their basic understanding of exploration and discovery.
"Subsurface discoveries of oil reserves cannot be projected with certainty. The inputs to the discoveries are always deterministic, but the result is never so, and there is a strong factor of probability. Exploration efforts are to reduce the risk factor and increase the probability of discovery. Methods for direct detection of hydrocarbons from the surface, are yet to be evolved. This contrasts with any other industry, where the output is more predictable and proportionate to the input.
.... As a simplistic approach the management decides the cost of discovery of one tonne of oil by dividing the amount of discovered oil by the expenditure met. It is expected by them that similar expenditure should proportionately result in additional discoveries.
When a sedimentary basin turns old and mature, the addition to the existing stock of subsurface oil becomes increasingly difficult. Non-geoscientists then blame geologists for such uncertainty. Only the high profitability in the oil industry is visible; its probabilistic nature and the risks involved are not so obvious. The stochastic nature of oil discoveries is not appreciated by non-explorationists".
My one complaint about this book is that there is very little geology in it! Dr. Deshpande describes the geology work he and others undertook in very broad strokes. I felt that a few examples of how specific types of geologic data is useful for petroleum exploration would be illuminating for the non specialist reader.
Let me give an example. Early in his career he is sent to Osmania University, Hyderabad, to analyze some sedimentary rock samples using Differential Thermal Analysis. He simply mentions that the results were used by ONGC in their exploration efforts, but how so? DTA is a way to understand whether the sedimentary rock was baked during burial to temperatures that are conducive for hydrocarbon formation.
Another example, and one that involves his specialization, could have been a brief passage describing his work on limestones. What is a carbonate sedimentologist looking for in these rocks? The main reservoir of Mumbai High, India's biggest oilfield, are Miocene age limestone beds which were deposited repeatedly during phases of oscillating sea level. Among other things, exploration geologists want to know how open spaces or porosity in these rocks has evolved over time and whether its occurrence can be predicted throughout the sedimentary section. There was a geological detective story waiting to be told there.
But these are mere quibbles. Overall, this is a very readable account of the productive and remarkable career of a pioneer exploration geologist of India. Popular accounts of Indian geology and industry are rare. Recently, Himalaya geology expert Dr. Om N. Bhargava released his memoir, Travails and Ecstasy of a Geologist Addicted to the Himalaya, on his experiences of working in the Himalaya. Indian earth scientists are beginning to share the good work they have done with a more general audience, bringing a much needed familiarity with a lesser appreciated but critical field of study.
I came across this lovely evocative passage in Nick Lane's book Transformer: The Deep Chemistry of Life and Death.
The passage describes the early Cambrian world (540-510 million years ago) which saw the rapid diversification of the animal biosphere. The ancestors of vertebrates had worm like bodies, and Anomalocaris, an early arthropod, was top predator. Much before, the garden of Ediacara was a very different place. Complex multicellular life appears in the fossil record from about 570 million years ago in the Ediacaran Period. These creatures were sessile (fixed to the sea floor) filter feeders with body shapes resembling large leaves and fronds. Evidence of mobile animals manifests by 550 million years ago. Their tracks, trails, and burrows are preserved in soft sediment.
The graphic shows this 'Edicaran biota', a term that includes a diverse and unrelated groups of organisms. Three distinct phases, termed Avalon, White Sea, and Nama, showing different community assemblages and increasing ecologic specialization are recognizable through the Ediacaran Period. Notice that mobile bilateral creatures first appear in the White Sea (B) assemblage.
Source: Rebecca Eden, Andrea Manica, Emily G. Mitchell: Plos Biology 2022.
Later in the chapter Nick Lane elaborates on how many of these Ediacaran filter feeders, simpler creatures without specialized tissues for different functions, could not cope with the anoxic sulpur rich environments and died out. Sponges notably did survive. Mobile animals though had evolved a rudimentary circulatory system and molecules like myoglobin and haemoglobin, capable of storing oxygen and removing carbon dioxide. When oxygen levels increased in the Cambrian their descendants had metabolic machinery to take advantage of this high-octane environment. The radiation of animals utterly transformed our world.
I highly recommend this book. It has a fair bit of chemistry in it. Nick Lane explains much of it using easier to follow diagrams instead of the dreaded chemical equations of our college years. He is a firm advocate of the metabolism first (as against a RNA/genes first) view of the origin of life and provides elegant explanations of energy flow and the evolution of metabolic pathways that build organic molecules to form biomass and breaks them up to power respiration. Disease and ageing is the inevitable consequence of the eventual degradation of these metabolic reactions.
At the heart of all this is the Kreb's cycle, a series of reactions which burn sugars in oxygen to generate energy for cellular functions. But the surprise is that much of life can get by with only a partial Kreb's cycle. In many microbes, it is not a cycle at all, but a short linear path. Not at all what our biochemistry book taught us and a lesson for creationists who insist that systems like the Kreb's Cycle are irreducible complex, a sign of intelligent design, which could not have evolved through incremental steps.
Nick Lane- Transformer: The Deep Chemistry of Life and Death.
Jyotirao Phule (1827-1890) was a social reformer from Maharashtra who worked for the emancipation of the lower castes and for improving the lives of peasant agriculturists. In Shetkaryacha Asud (The Cultivator's Whipcord), written in 1883, he describes the plight of poor farmers and offers some advice on improving yield through land management practices.
An excerpt-
The essence of leaf, grass, flower, dead insects and animals, is washed away by summer rain, therefore our industrious government should, as and when convenient, use the white and black soldiers and the extra manpower in the police department to construct small dams and bunds in such a way that this water should seep into the ground, and only later go and meet streams and rivers. This would make the land very fertile , and the soldiers in general, having got to working in [the] open air, will also improve their health and become strong.
.....Therefore the government should maintain these bunds in good condition, especially the backwaters. The government should conduct surveys of all the lands in its territory, employing water specialists, and wherever it is found that there is enough water to be drawn from more than one source, these places should be clearly marked in the maps of the towns, and the government should give some awards to farmers who dig wells without its assistance. Also the government should allow the farmer to collect all the silt and other things extracted from rivers and lakes, as in the older times, and it should also return all the cow pastures to the villages, which it has included in its 'forest'.
Phule covers many of the interventions that are recommended by watershed management specialists today. The last line of the passage I have quoted is telling. Preventing villagers from using what was traditionally considered 'village commons' has always been contested by the people. Phule also called for the destruction of the "oppressive Forest Department". The conflict between agriculturists, forest dwellers, pastoralists, and the forest department continues to this day.
This essay, translated from Marathi to English by Aniket Jaaware, has been republished in Makers of Modern India, a compilation of essays written through the 19th and 20th century by influential Indian political activists and social reformers. The collection is edited and introduced by historian Ramachandra Guha.
This passage from Helen Czerski's Blue Machine: How The Ocean Shapes Our World gives us a glimpse of the wondrous undersea universe we are just beginning to explore.
"We see upside-down waterfalls, she says. I don't understand what she means at first, and it takes me a few seconds to process the video as Deb keep talking. In those vertical chimneys, the walls crack and hydrothermal fluids come leaking out and you get something that looks like half a toadstool growing out of a tree in an old growth forest. And suddenly I see it. This is a gigantic hydrothermal chimney looming out of the darkness, and hot water is indeed leaking out of its side. But because hot water is less dense than cold water, the hot water keeps flowing rapidly upwards. When it first hits cold water, its clearly dumped some minerals and made a ledge that sticks out- that's the toadstool shape that Deb is referring to. The water flowing upwards has had to flow outwards underneath the ledge before it can carry on upwards. But the ledge has developed a hollow on its underside like an upside-down bowl, so there is a pool of hot water there, held in the hollow as if it were filling up the inside of an umbrella. The boundary between hot and cold water shimmers like a mirror. And then the hot water is spilling out of its hollow and continuing upwards into the gloom. It really is an upside down waterfall".
Helen Czerski is watching this footage captured by a remotely operated vehicle exploring the area around the Juan de Fuca Ridge, an undersea mountain chain a few hundred kilometers west of Seattle. Here, the Pacific and the Juan de Fuca tectonic plates diverge. Scientists are closely monitoring this ridge for seismic and volcanic activity, using a network of sensors called the Regional Cabled Array. Deb Kelly is the Director of this project. Hydrothermal chimneys are sulfide and carbonate mineral deposits that form when hot mineral saturated sea water emerges through cracks in the ocean crust. The are common near mid oceanic ridges where the interaction of sea water and rock heated up by magma generates vigorous hydrothermal systems.
I'm only a quarter into this book and am enjoying every page of it. Highly recommended!
These two books came highly recommended via friends and social media.
I loved the way Mala has used everyday analogies to describe complex geology. One of my favorite examples is using a stuck piano key to explain about fault block mountains. The stuck key is a horst or a block that has moved up relative to the adjacent depressed keys which are called grabens. India's mountains are geological varied. The Himalaya, the Satpura, and the Western Ghats, for example, have formed by very different processes. Mala has used clear language and everyday familiar examples to simplify explanations of their origins.
But this book is much more than about geology. Forests, wildlife, and human communities living in these rugged provinces really are the heart of the book. There are evocative descriptions of the animal and plant life of the different mountains ranges. Tibetan gazelles and mysterious snow leopards of the Himalaya, hoolock gibbons of the northeastern hills, majestic tigers of the Satpura and the Aravalli, and the bewildering varieties of frogs and reptiles of the Western Ghats, make us proud of our magnificent wildlife. There are lovely photographs scattered through the book. I could not stop gazing at the clouded leopard sitting elegantly on a branch deep in forests of the Mizo Hills.
People too have lived in these mountains and forests since times immemorial. Their lives and life practices are being threatened as more mountain and forest land is gobbled up for dams, mines and expanding townships. In the northern Aravallis, villagers fought for years to save the sacred grove of Mangar Bani. In the Nallamali hills of Andhra Pradesh, members of the Chenchu tribe along with other organizations protested uranium mining that would have transgressed on the Amrabad Tiger Reserve. The book tells many stories from across the country, from the Aravallis, to the Eastern Ghats, to the Himalaya, of people struggling to conserve forests and water sources.
Sketches and insets provide a welcome addition to the text. There are fun stories about the people of the mountains, about their crafts, about intrepid explorers, along with short quizzes, crammed in the insets that make the mountains come alive.
Mountain ranges form the most important watersheds of our big rivers. Today, rampant development of mountain slopes coupled with climate change are becoming big threats to our water security. Mala Kumar's urgent call for conservation and sustainable development emerges again and again throughout the book and she has chosen her audience well. Whom better to inculcate a love and awareness for nature than in our children. These young citizens will be living in an increasingly challenging world and the hope of changing it for the better lies in a deeper understanding of how nature works.
Go out for a trek in the mountains. Keep a lookout for that bright bluetail, and that curious langur who is peering at you half hidden from behind the thick leaves. Pick up pebbles from the stream bed and ask yourself about its geological secrets. Take a mountain train to the scented Nilgiri heights. If you are hesitating, this book is an ideal place to begin.
Up the Mountains of India: A Fun, Fact-Filled Trek across the Country's Major Ranges - Mala Kumar.
Naturalists exploring southern Scotland in the early nineteenth century came across some intriguing looking footprints impressed in red sandstone in a quarry at Corncockle Muir. The geologist Reverend Henry Duncan described these footprints and send some casts to the Reverend William Buckland who was making a name for himself in the emerging field of geology. The thinking was that these tracks were most likely made by crocodiles and turtles. Reverend Buckland came up with a clever way to test this idea.
From Elsa Panciroli's book-
'Ist I made a crocodile walk over soft pye-crust [sic]' he wrote in a letter to Duncan, 'and took impressions of his feet...[second] I made tortoises, of three distinct species, travel over pye-crust, and wet sand and soft-clay...' Buckland's wife supplied the pie-crust and Buckland supplied the tortoises. Where the crocodiles came from is unclear, but as Buckland had a penchant for eating them he probably also had access to live ones. The results : the marks matched the tortoises. He concluded, 'though I cannot identify them with any of the living species.... the form of the footsteps of a modern tortoise corresponds sufficiently well.... so I conceive your wild tortoises of the red sandstone age would move with more activity and speed... than my dull torpid prisoners.'
It was understood much later that these footprints in sand from Permian times (299 -252 million years ago) were made by early Therapsids from which arose the mammalian lineage.
I am really enjoying this book!
New arrivals on my book shelf.
Beasts Before Us: The Untold Story of Mammal Evolution and Origins. Untold because most authors begin where the Dinosaurs end. The starting point is usually at 66 million years ago, when a meteorite changed the world in an instant, reorganizing and vacating ecosystems into which mammalian lineages radiated. The story told by Elsa Panciroli goes way back, when Synapsids, the branch that led to mammals diverged from the common ancestor of mammals and reptiles. Repeat three times before going to sleep every night. Mammals did not evolve from Reptiles. These two groups shared a common ancestor in the Carboniferous about 300 million years ago. More and more fossils are revealing that these early mammalian lineages were quite diverse, and not mere stunted underlings to the more popularly known Dinosaurs. For a lucid audio discussion of this book, listen to Elsa Panciroli on Paleocast Podcast- Beasts Before Us.
Some geology and evolution material for your perusal.
1) I came across this well crafted documentary by Niles Eldredge and Stefano Dominici on the history of the development of ideas on the birth of species. It is a paleontologist's perspective with fossils being given the centre stage. A great many personalities who contributed to the early thinking on the origin of species are featured. Among the prominent ones who influenced Darwin were Lamarck, Cuvier, Giambattista Brocchi, and John Herschel to name a few. Completely left out of this film is Alfred Wallace.
It does center around Darwin, and, later towards the end, on Niles Eldredge's work on Punctuated Equilibrium, which he published in collaboration with Stephen Jay Gould. I have often wondered whether there was any tension between Eldredge and Gould regarding proprietorship over Punctuated Equilibrium given Gould's very bombastic advocacy of this idea. The last section of this film is revealing!
Beautifully compiled. Do watch.
If you are unable to access the embedded video, view it at this permanent link - The Birth of Species.
2) Zircon (zirconium silicate) is a remarkable mineral. Born in the cauldron of magma chambers, it is henceforth virtually indestructible unless it is melted down again. This makes it a witness to geological processes affecting and shaping terrains over hundreds of millions of years. What a story it has to tell us. And that is precisely what geochronologist Matthew Fox has done. He has written a children's book titled Jane's Geological Adventure, which follows Jane, the zircon grain, from her birth in a magma chamber to a life lasting 400 million years. Alka Tripathy-Lang reviews the book.
Meet Jane, the Zircon Grain—Geochronology’s New Mascot.
3) Elizabeth Pennisi writes about a new paper published in Nature Geosciences on the link between the increase in the length of the day and the rise of atmospheric oxygen on early earth.
‘Totally new’ idea suggests longer days on early Earth set stage for complex life.
James C. Scott in his book Against The Grain: A Deep History of the Earliest States makes the case for the transformational impact of fire on our environment.
The impact of human activity on the earth's outer skin has been so considerable that atmospheric chemist Paul Crutzen proposed that we are now living in a new geologic epoch, which he called the Anthropocene. This has sparked a vigorous debate on whether a new division of our time scale is justified, and if it is, on where to place its beginning. James C. Scott make a distinction between what he terms the "thick" Anthropocene, contrasting with the idea of a "thin" Anthropocene.
A "thick" Anthropocene is manifest by a sudden appearance of a worldwide signal of human activity. Examples of this could be the advent of the Industrial Revolution, or even more catastrophically, the nuclear age in the 1940's which left global radioactive markers. The "thick" Anthropocene appears to fit more closely geologic convention which demands that the beginning of a new geologic time unit need be recorded by a widespread and more or less synchronous preservation of biological and chemical changes.
Scott calls fire, agriculture, and domestication as part of the complex that comprises a "thin" Anthropocene. These inventions changed the world patchily and slowly. Its signals appear here and there, not encoded in one geologic layer, but in many, smeared over the past few hundred thousand years.
The term "more or less synchronous" I used to describe a new geologic boundary is relative to where in the geologic past the observer is. More recent changes are resolvable to a finer degree either as a matter of historical record or by methods like counting tree rings and annual/decadal growth layers in stalactites, cross calibrated by either carbon dating or some other radiometric dating method. The error bar increases as one goes further back in time. Take the great mass extinctions of the past. There will be a sediment layer to which a geologist can point to and state that this marks the boundary between say the Ordovician and the Silurian or the Permian and the Triassic. But that sediment layer certainly wasn't deposited instantaneously. It likely represents a few thousand years of elapsed time. If you were an observer who spent a few years in the Late Ordovician 443.8 million years ago, the situation would have been more akin to Scott's "thin" Anthropocene, with small changes occurring at different times in different places. You would have been unlikely to have anticipated the profound cumulative shift that would eventually accumulate.
Most mass extinctions which form the basis of the big divisions of geologic time unfolded over thousands of years, but their material record is collapsed into a few feet of sediment. We perceive these geologic turnovers as 'sudden' because the preceding and succeeding periods of relative stability lasted tens of millions of years and the time the 'boundary layer' spans is unresolvable using our current dating methods.
The exception to this is that fateful day 66.03 million years ago, when a large meteorite struck what is now the Yucatan Peninsula. By the time the dust had settled (literally) in a few weeks, the world had irrevocably changed. The Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary layer is in an absolute time sense a truly instantaneous deposit. We interpret it as instantaneous, not by radiometric dating, but by using our understanding of the physical sedimentation processes that would have been triggered by the impact.
The lesson we can draw from the transformational events from deep geological time is not about the debates over the timing of Anthropocene but on its effect. Like those distant ecologic disruptions, we too have set off biological, chemical and physical processes on a different trajectory than they were several thousands of years ago. The Anthropocene will leave a permanent mark on the many future worlds to come.
You didn't think I would stop at just three books, did you? More were delivered few days back.
New on my book shelf:
Sharing some interesting items:
1) What was the impact of Deccan Volcanism on the end-Cretaceous mass extinction? Improved dating of the timing of volcanism shows that volcanism spanned the mass extinction. But what changes occurred to marine environments because of the outgassing wasn't well documented. A new study uses the oxygen isotope ratios in foraminifera shells to estimate ocean temperature changes before and after the mass extinction. The finding is that the oceans warmed well before the extinction but cooled back again. The warming event doesn't appear to correlate with marine extinctions. Rather the mass extinction coincides with evidence for a meteorite impact.
Here is a figure from the paper on the estimated temperature changes collated using a variety of proxies:
Source: On impact and volcanism across the Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary
Joshua Sokol has written a good summary of the paper:
A Rapid End Strikes the Dinosaur Extinction Debate.
2) Anthropological geneticist Jennifer Raff has pieced together the genomic story of the peopling of the American continents in this really insightful article. Do read it!
Genomes Reveal Humanity’s Journey into the Americas.
The Tale of the Horse (video).
I came across this passage in Vipul Singh's interesting book, Speaking Rivers: Environmental History of A Mid-Ganga Flood Country, 1540-1885.
It is a section of the preamble of The Bengal Alluvion and Diluvion Regulation of 1825 which the East India Company passed to assure a regular income from Diara lands.
Diara land are ephemeral parcels of land that accrete to river banks or emerge in the middle of the river channel by sediment deposition. They can disappear in a decade or so as a major flood cuts away the river bank or erodes an island, only for newer land to appear elsewhere along this meandering fluid riverine landscape.
The satellite imagery covering the region between Patna in the west to Munger in the east forms the heart of this mid -Ganga floodplain.
Diara lands were traditionally farmed by landless peasants for the few months of the year that they were above water and then abandoned during monsoon inundation. There was no concept of ownership of these lands. The East India Company in its quest to maximize land revenue decided to regulate ownership of the Diara. It didn't always work in practice. Zamindars were reluctant to report the ground situation accurately and maps became outdated as topography and landscapes shifted quickly. Diara lands remained and still are a source of dispute.
Fascinating is the struggle outlined in the book of two long lasting empires with this river system. Before the Mughals, the Afghan ruler Sher Shah Suri occupied this region and had adapted to the capricious environment to his advantage. The Mughals though faced a different problem. Their power center was far to the west in Delhi and Agra. Carrying grains and goods from Bihar to Agra-Delhi using pack animals wasn't possible, since the expenses of feeding these animals would have left very little surplus. Being children of the Eurasian steppe, they preferred the horse and land transport, and that meant that they were unable or unwilling to develop a river navigation network on a commercial scale. The direction of river flow also worked against them. Sailing goods-laden boats upstream was challenging, especially as Vipul Singh points out, the Ganga upstream of Varanasi becomes difficult to negotiate. As a result the Mughals could never exploit or control this region fully.
The British though found the river to their liking. The Grant of Dewani of Bengal, which the East India Company won in 1765, extended to the mid Ganga floodplains. The Company's main port lay downstream in Calcutta and their major markets across the seas in China and Europe. Using their expertise in navigation they soon set up a thriving trade in saltpetre, calico, opium and silk. Slowly, they also began imposing a linear topography on these curving meandering rivers. The building of embankments, canals, and barrages was thought necessary to control the inundation that could lead to a loss of a cropping season. The various Regulations and Acts meant to ensure a permanent and uninterrupted stream of revenue ended up changing the people's interaction with the river.
These land regulations, beginning with the Permanent Settlement of 1793, entrenched the power of hereditary Zamindars who became Company rent collecting agents. It became especially hard for the landless to eke out a living as they saw even the ephemeral parcels of Diara which they had been farming now being allocated to the nearest Zamindar and his tenants. Large scale flood control projects carried out by Zamindars and encouraged by Company revenue officers began reshaping the ecology of the floodplains with embankments preventing floods in one region but exacerbating them on the opposite side or in downstream areas. Embankments also prevented smaller local streams from draining into the larger rivers, resulting in the water-logging of fields. Praveen Singh in The colonial state, zamindars and the politics of flood control in north Bihar (1850-1945), details how a web of social and economic interests spurred on this construction spree despite warnings from irrigation engineers about the detrimental effects of embankments.
Vipul Singh also emphasizes the linkage between physical processes and cultural evolution. A unique Bihari regional identity emerged based on the homogeneous ecology, similar agrarian practices and a shared reverence for the Ganga.
The Ganga of the plains is a turbid river. It transports several hundred million tons of sediment to the Delta. In this section of Bihar, it is joined by the Sone from the
south and the Ghaghara, the Gandak and the Kosi from the north. The Kosi
and the Gandak are especially sediment rich, carrying a suspended
sediment load of 80 million
tons per year and 43 million tons per year respectively. All this sediment is what makes this region special. A significant
fraction of it gets deposited every year in the river channel
and its floodplains. Over time, the Ganga and its tributaries have built vast alluvial deposits, through which the river finds its way, often getting choked on its own sediment, and then breaking free by cutting a new path for itself. This abundance of
water and sediment has formed a complex fluvial ecosystem of meandering
channels, river islands, abandoned courses, oxbox lakes, ponds, and
wetlands. The organic rich silt deposited across floodplains by the
rivers during monsoon inundation nourishes multiple crops. Life's daily rhythms became embedded in this ecology and its inhabitants evolved farming practices adapted to the changing tune of the environment.
There was linguistic pride too, not in one common 'Bihari' language, but in the various dialects spoken 'eh /e paar' and 'oh o paar'; this side of the Ganga and on the other side. Bhojpuri was the dialect of the Champaner area north of the Ganga, while to its east on the north side was spoken Maithili. In the Patna region on the south side was Magahi and towards the east near about Munger was Angika. These vernaculars with their common folk tales, poetry, and myths about deities, changing seasons, local plants and animals, and the Ganga, knitted the region together, away from the pull of the Delhi-Agra-Awadhi influence which lay to the west and the Bengali cultural sphere towards the east.
Magh ke garmi, Jeth ke jar
Pahila pani bhar gail tar,
Ghag kahen ham hoban jogi,
Kuan ka pani dhoihen dhobi.
[Heat in Magh (January-February), cold in Jeth (May-June),and the tanks filled with the first fall of rain, are the signs of drought. Ghagh says that I will become a beggar, and the washer-men will wash with well-water.]
This is a gem of a book. Highly recommended reading!
Ordered and received!
Happy Reading.
