Inspiration From The Galapagos Islands

From the famous Galapagos Islands comes news about a link between global warming and intensification of El Nino.

 

Imagery- Sentinel 2 Mosaic: Copernicus Browser

El Nino is a pattern of natural climatic variation which occurs when a weakening or reversal of easterly trade winds results in warm Pacific water piling up around the west coast of South America. This phenomenon depends upon subtle interactions between sea surface temperature, ocean currents, and winds, and climate models can’t reproduce these accurately. This means that often different models disagree on how El Nino might be affected by global warming.  Historical records don’t go too far back for us to assess whether there is a clear correlation between global warming and El Nino strength.

Now, a new method uses corals to tease out the temperature of sea water across centuries.

Coral skeletons grow by precipitating the mineral aragonite (CaCO3) in yearly growth bands. Scientists sampled these layers and measured the amount of element strontium and the ratio of heavy oxygen O18 to the lighter O16 in each layer. Aragonite incorporates less strontium and more O16 in warmer water. A sea surface temperature record stretching back a thousand years could be constructed.

The conclusion was that over the past 40 years, temperature swings have become more extreme in El Nino years. This finding from the Galapagos is complimented by another analysis of corals from Kiribati in the Central Pacific. Scientist have a taken a step towards a firmer understanding of the variability of this phenomenon which causes extreme weather events around the globe.

Which other important scientific studies have come out of the Galapagos?

Ahem… there is off course the visit in the year 1835 by a certain Mr. Charles Darwin. His observations there made an important but not an outsized contribution towards his theories of evolution. Darwin was just as comfortable driving home his point using the example of the domesticated pigeon as he was describing the finches and mockingbirds of the Pacific Islands.

Jeff Wallace of the University of Glamorgan in his brilliant introduction to the Wordsworth Classics of World Literature edition of The Origin of Species makes this observation: 

"Readers thus soon find themselves continually shuttled to and fro across the distance between the ‘familiar’ and the ‘other’, the domestic and the exotic, in a text which seems to disdain the very boundary lines between such distinctions. With bewildering and unpredictable variation, we encounter the women-eating barbarians of Terra del Fuego; the small Asiatic cockroach; the thickened stems of the common  and Swedish turnip; the climbing hooks  used by the trailing bamboo of the Malay Archipelago; the egg carrying folds of skin of pendunuculated centipedes; the northern and southern downs of the Weald; the sedimented beds of the mouth of the Mississippi during the glacial period. Darwin’s task at once scientifically central to his work and yet only to be achieved through a vivid and creative use of language, is to make strange or 'astonishing’ the detail of the close and familiar world, and to bring the most extraordinary facets of the alien and unknown within the realms of common understanding. His success, in a text whose fascination is undiminished if not growing as we enter the peculiar concerns of the millennium, lies ultimately in indicating that these contrasting worlds are in fact one world".  

The variation in the beak of the Galapagos ground finches and mockingbirds did inspire Darwin to think about common descent and natural selection, but the legendary finches don’t even feature in his book. The reason is he failed to label his collection systematically! On his return to England he did turn over his collection of wrens, blackbirds, and finches to the ornithologist John Gould.

To his surprise, Gould informed him that despite the great differences in their beak shape and size, the ‘wrens’ and ‘blackbirds’ were in fact all ground finches. His grab bag collection was actually a closely related group of 13 species of finches. Darwin did label his collection of four mockingbirds by island, and they too, as Gould found out, were distinct species. Gould added one more crucial piece of information. All these birds had close but not identical relatives on the American mainland.

Darwin eventually saw the significance of this observation and it became an important piece of evidence for his theory of common descent. He hypothesized that one founder population of these birds must have reached the Galapagos from the South American mainland and then diverged into distinct species on different islands. The standard depiction of an evolutionary tree with branches splitting away from a common node owes its origins to the rather disorganized collection of a wide thinking naturalist and the keen observation of an ornithologist.

Many decades later two scientists did label those finches correctly. And studied them in excruciating detail.

 I am referring to Rosemary and Peter Grant’s epic 40 year study of the morphological evolution of the ground finches of the Galapagos. These two scientists painstakingly measured the variation in beak size and shape over many generations. This they complimented by comparing their genetic differences, and using all this data pieced together a tale of their evolution through changing climate patterns and food availability. Their study has provided a powerful validation of Darwin’s idea that natural selection can shape morphologic change and specialization in populations.

Jonathan Weiner’s Pulitzer Prize winning book, The Beak of the Finch, captures this story vividly. A more updated description of this research has been provided by the two scientists themselves through their publication - 40 Years Of Evolution: Darwin’s Finches On Daphne Major Island.

The Galapagos Islands began forming about 4 million years ago. The Nazca tectonic plate is moving eastwards in the Pacific over a heat source situated deep in the earth’s mantle. The eastern edge of the Nazca Plate is sinking beneath the South American tectonic plate. Sporadic volcanism over the mantle hot spot has created a chain of volcanic islands which become younger towards the west. Volcanoes on the western islands are still active.Today, the islands and the surrounding waters are a marine reserve, offering some protection to its unique biodiversity.

Although geologically young, the specific geologic and bio-geographic circumstance of these islands have proven to be a fertile ground for science. From climate change, to evolution, to conservation biology, scientists working there continue to probe and tease out insights that are proving crucial in navigating the currents of a rapidly changing world.

Early Animal Evolution - Fecal Matter

A paper published a few weeks ago on the topic of early animal evolution in the journal Trends in Ecology and Evolution caught my eye. The time period I am referring to is the Early Cambrian, roughly 539 -510 million years ago. A great diversification of animal life occurred during this interval. Many explanations for this phase of rapid animal evolution have been put forth. Expanded shallow marine habitat due to continental rearrangements, an increase in dissolved oxygen, an influx of calcium and zinc to the oceans from continental weathering, both essential for physiologic function and shell building (in case of calcium), and predator prey arms races that drove evolution of novel morphology.

The recent study by Julien Kimming and Russel Bicknell proposes that fecal matter that early animals were expelling also played a role in Cambrian animal radiation. Fecal matter is preserved as lumps of calcium carbonate known as coprolites. 

Examples of these Cambrian coprolites are shown in the collage below. They are generally centimeter to millimeter in size.

 Source- Russel and Kimmig: Trends in Ecology and Evolution, August 2026. 

The fecal lumps also contain crushed shells and disseminated organic matter containing nitrogen and phosphorous. As animals with guts became common, so did fecal pellets. These pellets began sinking into the deeper parts of oceans, bringing nutrients to previously sparsely occupied environments. Habitats increased along with more complex food webs. I’ll be writing more about early animal evolution soon, although focusing on a very different kind of fossil evidence. Stay tuned.

The author's summary of their work has been published in The Conversation.

Geology Word: Ooid

Ooids are sedimentary grains that form by precipitation of calcium carbonate around a nucleus. The nucleus may be an organic particle, or a mineral grain, or a shell fragment.

Repeated precipitation results in a concentric coating around the nucleus. Depending upon the saturation state of the sea and other variables like temperature, ooids may be made up of either calcite or aragonite. Both have the same chemical formula, CaCO3, but they differ in their atomic structure.

Ooids form in shallow seas where wave energy is vigorous. The turbulence results in the particles getting suspended and redeposited on the sea floor, resulting in an even coating around the nucleus. Beaches, tidal channels and regions near reefs are areas where ooids are accumulating today in tropical seas around the Bahamas, Caribbean, the Persian Gulf, and the Red Sea.

The picture shows an ancient ooid. This particle is around 350 million years old from the Mississippian Period, deposited in a warm shallow sea which occupied the State of Alabama in North America. I collected the rock sample on a field trip during my PhD days.

Interestingly, the nucleus is a foraminifera, a unicellular protist! Observe the coiled nature of the shell with its internal chambers visible. The shell of the foraminifera is also calcium carbonate and its precipitation is mediated by the organism. On the other hand, ooids results from an inorganic precipitation process, although there is evidence of bacterial involvement in some examples.

In the Precambrian (older than 539 million years ago), before animals evolved and began constructing shells, limestones were mostly made up of fine calcium carbonate mud. Precambrian calcium carbonate sand ( any sedimentary particle, irrespective of composition, between .063 mm and 2 mm is defined as sand) is rare, composed almost exclusively of ooids and a category of grains known as intraclasts (broken fragments of hardened sea floor).

The distribution of ooids and shell types through geologic history is a pointed reminder of how life has impacted the texture and composition of sedimentary rocks.

Deposited in high energy shoals, ooids help geologists reconstruct ancient environments and the paleogeography of continents which were flooded in the deep past.

Ooids are of interest to petroleum geologists too. The spherical grains result in a packing arrangement with high porosity (open spaces between grains). The localization of ooid layers in ancient sedimentary basins is keenly explored for their petroleum reservoir potential.

That was fun to write. I may turn this into a Geology Word series.

Bengal Delta, Africa Rifting, India Sand Mining

A few readings for your perusal- 

1) The future of Bengal Delta. With this succinct title Dipen Bhattacharya has written an informative article on the origin and evolution of the Bengal Delta. The Bay of Bengal was created when India broke away from eastern Antarctica about 130 -120 million years ago in the early mid Cretaceous. The basin expanded as India drifted northwards. From Cretaceous to Oligocene times (120-25 million years ago) rivers from Peninsular India were providing most of the sediment being deposited in the Bay. Himalaya derived sediment started overwhelming Peninsular river input from about 25 million years ago. K.S. Krishna and coworkers have very elegantly demonstrated this in their study of sediment pathways in to the Bay of Bengal.

Dr. Bhattacharya has traced the evolution of the delta into more recent times, explaining the role of the Pleistocene ice ages in delta growth. The delta’s future too is at risk with dam building and ground water extraction amplifying the changes due to global warming induced sea level rise. Well worth reading.

2) Eastern Africa Is Splitting Apart, but Not Where We Expected.  Africa is tearing apart along a north south oriented corridor from the Red Sea to Mozambique. Plate motion has formed the famous rift valleys of Ethiopia, Kenya, and Tanzania, as the crust stretches and subsides along faults. Kimberley Cartier explains the geological set up of the region and the stages in which continents break apart with oceanic basins eventually forming along the initial zones of continental rifts.

Why this region of Africa is rifting is not all that easy to explain. If you look at the plate tectonic map of Eastern Africa and the adjacent Indian Ocean and Arabian Sea you will notice that the oceanic Somalia and Indian Ocean tectonic plates are pushing into East Africa. For continents to split and be pulled apart, there have to be extensional forces generated. These are usually provided at the locus of rifting by the mantle doming up, thereby breaking and pushing the lithosphere away, and by one end of the plate subducting underneath another overriding plate. The subducting oceanic crust becomes denser and heavier as it sinks deeper, pulling the rest of the plate with it.

After the breakup of Gondwanaland, the northerly movement of the India plate through the Cretaceous was sustained by the pull force of the northern edge of the India plate sinking under Asia. On the other hand, Eastern Africa is surrounded by plate spreading zones. There is no pull force available for eastern Africa, only the localized extensional stresses due to mantle upwelling.  Is that providing adequate horizontal traction at the base of the Africa Plate for the crust to break apart and stretch? For a deeper understanding into the mantle forces responsible for this, I will recommend J Micheal Kendall and Carolina Lithgow-Bertelloni ‘s article- Why is Africa Rifting?

3)  India’s rivers bear lasting scars from relentless sand mining. Some years ago I heard a podcast on Planet Money about a Jamaican beach that was stolen. An estimated 500 truckloads of sand was hauled away in the middle of the night. Sand is big business all over the world. Indian river beds too are being plundered for their sand to satisfy the demands of the booming construction industry. Sahana Ghosh explores how scientists are surveying Indian rivers using field observations and satellite data. They are trying to track down the amount of sand being extracted and the environmental impact of sand mining.

Photo: Insect Camouflage

 I nearly missed this insect as I was sipping my evening coffee.

The rust, black, and white pattern of the insect blends into the pink feldspar, biotite, and quartz of the granite table top. When the restaurant introduced these tables in the 1980’s, insects with a passing resemblance to the table colors survived the gaze of bird predators better than individuals of the same species not having that coloration. Granite colored insects reproduced more, and the match between the insect patterning and the table top became more fine tuned over time.

I made this up. It is what is known as a “Just So Story”, named after writer Rudyard Kipling’s Just So Stories for children. Kipling wrote imaginative fantastical explanations for how animals looked the way they do. The term made its way into biology and was especially used, rather derisively, by evolutionary biologist Stephen Jay Gould as a critique of evolutionary psychology. Gould complained that the field tends to come up with imaginative yet unsupported adaptationist explanations for every aspect of human behavior. They are Just So Stories. The criticism has extended to other areas of biology too. Such as one can make about my story of the insect.

How did this particular insect species get this coloration that matches the granite? Likely its historical origins lies in a very different environment. Perhaps adaptation through natural selection in an ecologic setting of leaves and colored pebbles did play a role in the evolution of this pattern. Or perhaps it is a side effect of some other developmental changes in the insect body plan. Whatever the explanation, it is only chance that its coloration matches the table top stone.